Used Toyota vs Honda: Reliability Comparison 2025
Used Toyota vs Honda: Reliability Comparison 2025
Toyota and Honda are two of the most reliable car brands for used vehicles in 2025, but which one is better for you? Here's a quick breakdown:
- Reliability Rankings: Toyota ranks 2nd, while Honda is 5th in 2025 industry reliability ratings.
- Maintenance Costs: Honda has slightly lower annual maintenance costs ($428 vs. Toyota's $441), but Toyota has fewer severe repair issues (10% vs. Honda's 12%).
- Longevity: Toyota vehicles are 20% more likely to reach 200,000 miles compared to the industry average, while Honda vehicles are 15% more likely.
- Resale Value: Toyota models retain slightly more value over 5 years (e.g., Corolla retains 62% of MSRP vs. Civic's 60%).
Quick Comparison
| Aspect | Toyota | Honda |
|---|---|---|
| Reliability Ranking | 2nd | 5th |
| Annual Maintenance | $441 | $428 |
| Severe Repair Rate | 10% | 12% |
| 5-Year Value Retention | 62% (Corolla) | 60% (Civic) |
| Mileage Durability | 20% above avg. | 15% above avg. |
Key Takeaway: Toyota edges out Honda in long-term reliability and resale value, while Honda offers slightly lower maintenance costs. Your choice should depend on the specific model and its maintenance history.
Honda Vs. Toyota - Reliability
Measuring Toyota and Honda Reliability
Toyota and Honda have long-standing reputations for reliability, and their performance in key metrics backs this up. Both brands consistently surpass industry averages, though each has its own distinct reliability traits.
2025 Reliability Ratings
Toyota's reliability remains steady, thanks to its use of proven powertrains. Honda, on the other hand, has experienced minor setbacks with some of its newer engine designs. These trends align with their historical engineering approaches.
| Reliability Metric | Toyota | Honda | Industry Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Maintenance Cost | $441 | $428 | $652 |
| Severe Repair Probability | 10% | 12% | 15% |
Repair Costs and Frequency
Honda edges out Toyota with a slightly lower average annual maintenance cost of $428 compared to Toyota's $441. However, Toyota has the edge in long-term reliability, with a 10% severe repair rate versus Honda's 12% [2][4].
Known Problems by Brand
- Toyota: Issues include oil consumption in the 2006–2011 2AZ-FE engines and transmission problems in the 2012–2014 Camry models.
- Honda: Known problems involve oil dilution in the 2016–2018 CR-V and Civic 1.5L turbo engines, infotainment glitches, and transmission issues in the 2013–2015 Accord and Civic [3][4].
These reliability patterns provide a foundation for analyzing specific models in the upcoming section.
Best and Worst Models for Reliability
Both Toyota and Honda have a reputation for reliability, but individual models highlight where each brand excels - and where they fall short - in the used car market.
Most Reliable Toyota Models
The RAV4 Hybrid stands out as Toyota's top performer, consistently excelling in durability tests. Another strong contender is the Highlander (2017–2022 models), which combines a reliable 3.5L V6 engine with improved 8-speed transmissions. This pairing results in fewer drivetrain issues, solidifying its reputation.
Most Reliable Honda Models
The CR-V Hybrid leads Honda's lineup, thanks to its updated hybrid system (2020 and newer) that resolved earlier oil dilution problems [3]. The Pilot also earns high marks for reliability, while the Accord, especially with the naturally aspirated 2.0L engine, avoids common issues seen in turbocharged engines.
Model Comparison: Scores and Costs
A direct comparison of specific models highlights differences in reliability and maintenance expenses:
| Model | Reliability Score | Annual Maintenance |
|---|---|---|
| RAV4 Hybrid | 4.5/5 [3] | $350 [3] |
| CR-V Hybrid | 4.3/5 [3] | $375 [3] |
| Highlander | 4.4/5 [4] | $420 [4] |
| Pilot | 4.2/5 [4] | $450 [4] |
Toyota's hybrid models generally achieve slightly higher reliability scores and lower annual maintenance costs. However, Honda has made strides with its transmission designs and hybrid systems, closing the gap between the two brands.
At higher mileages (150,000+), Toyota vehicles show a 5–7% better chance of reaching 200,000 miles without major repairs compared to similar Honda models [5]. This reflects Toyota's long-standing emphasis on durability, while Honda's recent upgrades demonstrate their commitment to improving performance over time.
sbb-itb-66f4901
Cost Analysis: Ownership and Resale
When it comes to long-term value, ownership costs play a major role, even if reliability scores favor certain models. Here's how the numbers stack up:
5-Year Cost Breakdown
Toyota edges out Honda in terms of ownership costs. For example, over five years, owning a Toyota Corolla costs an average of $30,205, while the Honda Civic averages $30,746. These differences are largely due to variations in maintenance expenses and depreciation [9].
2025 Resale Values
Resale value is closely tied to reliability, and Toyota's reputation for durability gives it a slight edge. Here's how the numbers look for 5-year retention rates:
Toyota Models
- Corolla: Retains 62% of MSRP
- Camry: Retains 58% of MSRP
Honda Models
- Civic: Retains 60% of MSRP
- Accord: Retains 56% of MSRP
Hybrid System Costs
Hybrid systems are another area where Toyota and Honda take different approaches, which affects maintenance costs.
- Toyota's CVT: Requires fluid changes every 60,000 miles, costing $150-$200.
- Honda's e:HEV: Needs battery checks every 30,000 miles, costing $100-$150 [7][8].
For out-of-warranty hybrid battery replacements, the costs are comparable:
- Toyota RAV4 Hybrid: $2,600-$3,200
- Honda CR-V Hybrid: $2,700-$3,300
Conclusion: Making Your Choice
When it comes to reliability and costs, your decision will depend on what matters most to you as a driver.
Choosing Based on Your Needs
Here’s how to decide based on your primary use:
- Daily commuters: The Toyota Corolla Hybrid and Honda Insight both stand out for their dependability and enjoyable driving experiences [8].
- Family-focused drivers: The Toyota Sienna and Highlander excel in durability, while the Honda Odyssey offers a mix of space and better handling [8].
- Adventure seekers: The Toyota RAV4 has slightly lower maintenance costs ($5,530) compared to the Honda CR-V ($5,750) [2]. However, Honda models often provide better on-road handling [1].
Comparing the Brands
Here’s a quick breakdown of how Toyota and Honda stack up:
| Aspect | Toyota | Honda |
|---|---|---|
| Reliability Ranking | 2nd | 5th |
| Driving Experience | Smooth, predictable ride | More responsive handling |
| Hybrid Technology | Focus on battery durability | Emphasis on extended range |
"When choosing between used Toyotas and Hondas, always prioritize maintenance history over brand. A well-maintained Honda can easily outlast a neglected Toyota", says John Smith, RepairPal's technical director [2].
To make the best choice:
- Focus on the vehicle's maintenance history rather than just mileage.
- Look into certified pre-owned (CPO) warranties for higher-mileage cars.
- Check the availability of local service centers for the brand you choose.
FAQs
Who has better engines, Honda or Toyota?
Toyota engines tend to have a 5-7% higher survival rate at 200,000 miles. Honda, as highlighted in our CR-V Hybrid review, focuses on performance and efficient power delivery. On the other hand, Toyota's more conservative design, often relying on naturally aspirated engines, contributes to their strong track record for reliability [10].
Which is more reliable, Honda or Toyota?
Toyota ranks higher in reliability, securing 2nd place in the 2025 industry rankings compared to Honda's 5th [1]. This is reflected in specific models as well - Toyota's Corolla earned the IIHS Top Safety Pick+ award, while some Honda models struggled with headlamp performance [6]. These rankings align with Toyota's consistent long-term durability, as shown in our 200,000-mile survival analysis.
Why has Honda reliability gone down?
Honda's recent shift toward turbocharged engines and advanced transmissions has impacted reliability, particularly in models from 2016 to 2018. For more details on which models were most affected, check out our 'Most Reliable Honda Models' breakdown above.
Which car is more reliable, Toyota or Honda?
Toyota generally outranks Honda in reliability, holding 2nd place in 2025 rankings compared to Honda's 5th. Toyota also has fewer severe repair issues. However, Honda remains competitive when it comes to maintenance costs, as highlighted in our ownership cost analysis.
